The Pros and Cons of Press #3
A further round-up of responses to the album…
Whisperinandhollerin did a very cool feature on us last year, but as it’s a site with numerous different writers we didn’t take it for granted that the album would be received equally well. We were therefore overjoyed to read this nine-out-of-ten review:
Rock ‘n’ Reel’s R2 magazine was similarly enthusiastic, giving the album a thoughtful and measured four-out-of-five review:
Craig Haggis of Porky Prime Cuts praises the effort that went into the press package. Thanks Craig, we wrote and designed that ourselves… we ARE the record label!
“The Pros and Cons … is a challenging album, consuming the sounds of the Balkans, musical theatre and the New Wave of New Wave, not always deliberately. It ends up as a stir fry using leftovers and flavours that clash, providing a 41-minute dish that both sparkles the tastebuds and leaves you feeling bloated. I can think of the Libertines… in using intelligence with pace; glamour with individuality.”
Pierre’s review at La Blogotheque has tested our rusty schoolboy French to its limits. Even with the help of Google Translate, we’re none the wiser. If you’re more au fait with the French tongue than us, check it out.
Subba-Cultcha covers all bases, describing the album as “a sort of slightly forceful folky pop rock”. Mind you, the reviewer also compares the German passage in Sleeping Lions to an excerpt from a Hitler speech. We respectfully suggest that he translates it!
“The thing with this album is half of the songs are brilliant and the other half are distinctly average, making makes this album more lopsided than a table with only two legs. Fans of Lupen Crook’s earlier work will love this record and everyone else will love half this record.”
Over at Velvet Coalmine, Rhian Jones subjects the album to a characteristically rigorous analysis, picking up on its themes of “the crooked, the feral, the raw, the hopelessly romantic” and concluding that:
“The Pros and Cons of Eating Out… maintains the same dignified distance from the mainstream and the metropolis which granted Crook’s debut a distinction from the post-Libertines litter, and which continues to set him apart from his peers.”
Finally, congratulations to The Medway Broadside on its launch yesterday. What better way to celebrate than with a Lupen Crook album review?
Can’t say fairer than that. Hg x

















